Skip to main content
Eevy.ai
← All How-To Guides
Reviews

How to Filter and Sort Reviews by Rating

2026-04-013 min read

Why This Matters

When a product has dozens or hundreds of reviews, shoppers do not read them all. They scan, filter, and jump to the reviews that answer their specific concerns. If your review section does not let customers filter by star rating, they are stuck scrolling through a wall of text hoping to find what they need. That friction costs you conversions.

Rating filters serve two distinct shopper behaviors. First, cautious shoppers immediately filter to one- and two-star reviews to understand the worst-case scenario. If the worst complaints are about minor issues ("shipping took an extra day") rather than product quality, that shopper is reassured. Second, comparison shoppers filter to four- and five-star reviews to quickly understand what people love most about the product. Both behaviors move shoppers closer to a purchase decision.

Sortable reviews also reduce bounce rates on product pages. Shoppers who can quickly find relevant reviews stay on the page longer and convert at higher rates. Without filtering, a shopper might see their first three reviews and none address their specific concern — about sizing, durability, or color accuracy — and leave. With filtering, they can find exactly the reviews they need in seconds.

Step-by-Step Guide

1

Enable rating filter controls in your review widget

Navigate to your review app's display settings and enable the rating filter or sort options. Eevy AI provides built-in rating filter bars that show the distribution of ratings (how many one-star, two-star, etc.) and let shoppers click to filter. Enable this feature to give customers control over their review browsing experience.

2

Display a rating distribution bar

Add a visual breakdown showing the count or percentage of reviews at each star level. This horizontal bar chart gives shoppers an instant overview of your rating distribution before they start filtering. A distribution skewed toward four and five stars builds confidence; a U-shaped distribution (lots of fives and ones) raises flags.

3

Add sort options beyond rating

Include sort options for "Most Recent," "Most Helpful," and "Has Photos" alongside the rating filter. Multiple sort dimensions help different shopper types find what they need. Some want the latest feedback, others want the most upvoted reviews, and visual shoppers want to see photos first.

4

Ensure filters work on mobile

Test the filter and sort controls on mobile devices where tap targets need to be at least 44 pixels. Dropdown menus often work better than horizontal button rows on mobile. Ensure the filtered results load instantly without a full page refresh — shoppers expect immediate feedback when applying filters.

Pro Tip

Eevy AI's genetic algorithm can test different default sort orders — most recent, highest rated, or most helpful — to find which initial ordering drives the highest conversion rate for your store.

Free — 30 seconds

Is your product page losing sales right now?

Most Shopify PDPs we scan have 4+ fixable conversion gaps. Paste your URL and get a scored audit instantly.

Get my free audit →

Related reading

Guide

Review Strategy for Dropshipping Stores

Build trust and overcome skepticism with reviews on your dropshipping store.

Guide

How to Enable Eevy Add-ons

Enable Eevy Add-ons to display star ratings, review counts, and social proof widgets anywhere on your Shopify store.

How-to

How to Set Up a Review Rewards Program

Create an incentive program that motivates customers to leave reviews on your Shopify store. Increase review volume by 3-5x with the right reward structure.

How-to

How to Collect Video Reviews from Customers

Proven strategies to get customers to submit video reviews on your Shopify store. Build an authentic UGC library that drives conversions.

Article

Trustpilot vs Yotpo (2026): Brand vs Product Reviews

Yotpo vs Trustpilot compared: company-level trust vs on-page product reviews, real pricing, and which your Shopify store actually needs in 2026.

Article

Ali Reviews vs Loox: Imported Reviews or Visual Social Proof? (2026)

Ali Reviews vs Loox compared. AliExpress review import for dropshipping vs premium photo and video reviews for DTC brands. Pricing, free plans, and which fits your store.

Tip

Add Star Rating Filters to Your Review Section

Rating filters let shoppers find the reviews they trust most. Learn why letting customers filter by star rating increases conversion, not decreases it.

Tip

Create a Dedicated Review Collection Landing Page

A dedicated review collection page gives customers one place to leave reviews for any product. Learn how to build and promote a review landing page on Shopify.

Problem

Low Average Order Value

Your Shopify store average order value is below industry benchmarks. Learn how AI-optimized review layouts build product confidence and encourage larger.

Problem

Declining Conversion Rate

Your Shopify store conversion rate is trending downward. Discover how continuous AI-driven A/B testing adapts your review layouts to changing shopper behavior.

Glossary

Average Rating

Average rating is the arithmetic mean of all star values across a product's or store's reviews, typically displayed to one decimal place (e.g. 4.7) and shown alongside the review count as the headline social-proof number.

Glossary

Review Count

Review count is the total number of reviews displayed for a product or store, shown beside the star rating (e.g. "4.7 from 1,247 reviews") and used by both shoppers and search engines as a volume-of-social-proof signal.

Free — no account needed

See exactly what's costing you conversions

Paste your product URL. Get a scored Shopify PDP audit in 30 seconds — then see how Eevy AI fixes every gap.

Scan my store →

Skip the manual work. Let AI optimize.

Eevy AI's genetic algorithm runs these optimizations automatically, testing layouts 24/7 to find what converts best for your store.

Try Eevy AI Free